Skip to main content

WRITTEN LAW IS NOT ALWAYS EQUIVALENT TO JUSTICE

In The Caucasian Chalk Circle, the Written law is not always equivalent to justice. Justify this statement basing your illustration on the Play.
Many modern-day societies are built around the written law. Such law defines the sovereignty, powers and the rights of each individual. However, the laws also dictate the limitations to such rights and their impact. In the play, The Caucasian Chalk Circle, Bertolt Brecht observes that sometimes, the written law is not always justice. 

In the prologue, the old man representing the Rosa Luxembourg, exclaims that the disputed land belongs to them by law upon which, the Girl Tractorist observes that such laws ought to be changed. Although this is an indicator of the changing rules, it also postulates the new norm -  a norm that transcends laws that have refused to keep up with the changing society.

During the times when Azdak was judge, the written rule becomes the judge's cushion. Instead of following the written law, Azdak follows the common law to pass judgment. According to the law, a person found with illegally acquired goods must be charged with theft. However, when an old woman is accused of stealing from three farmers, instead of Azdak charging her for theft, he claims that the stolen cow and ham were in the woman’s possession by miracle. He reprimands the tree farmer for not believing in miracles and fines them. Although Azdak broke the written law, his keen sense of seeing beyond the law reveals the woman as a victim of circumstance and therefore rewards her for suffering in a highly individualized society.

In another case, Azdak finds a man- a stableman- accused of rape innocent. Rape is a highly emotive issue especially in the present day society where the Me Too campaign is urging women to speak about the atrocities committed against them by the menfolk. In the play, Azdak is confronted by a caring father-in-law (inn Keeper) who sues a stableman for raping the wife of the son who was in war. After observing the case keenly, Azdak rules in favour of the stableman and fines the Inn Keeper commanding him to surrender the beloved roan to the court.
Finally, when Natella comes back to claim the child, Azdak uses unconventional means to give the child to the real mother. In as much as the law allows for the real mother to be biological, in this case, Azdak’s law allowed the real mother to be humane and considerate- not driven by greed for power vested in the child.


In the case Azdak ruled, if he had followed the written law, the gullible and the greedy would have had their day. However, in retrospect, the weak enjoyed Azdak’s ruling getting justice without buying. Although Azdak could be seen as having broken written law, his judgment nevertheless rendered the deserved justice. 

Comments

Post a Comment

Popular posts from this blog

VIHIGA COUNTY- THE ECONOMY, IN FOCUS: MUDETE TEA FACTORY, A WATER DOWN OR ???

         Mudete Tea Factory is located in Vihiga county of Western Kenya. The factory Is to serve the Tea rich Western Kenya especially Vihiga county which receives an annual rainfall of about 1500mm to 2000mm. The factory established in the mid 1990s has seen a fair share of progress but has remained a dimunitive figure in the progress of the county. One could argue that maybe it is due to the fact that the tea farmers within the region are much less reluctant in upping their game to produce higher and quality tea for the factory. The factory which is supposed to run on a 24hour basis goes on occasions where it runs out of tea to process!Clearly someone is sleeping on the job. the wellbieng of this factory fundamentally lies in two people; the farmer and the farmer.therefore this factory can only be a success story if the farmer realised how much he can reap from the factory. But one problem comes into mind when you talk about the farmer not del...
3 comments
Read more

EXPLORING FEMINISM IN BLOSSOMS OF THE SAVANNAH AND A DOLL'S HOUSE

Feminism emerged as a movement to fight for the social, political and economic rights of the women. It is more of a political movement that recognises the individuality and sexuality of women and how historically and religion wise have been segregated. Before the advent of feminism, women lived under the tutelage of their male counterparts. For instance, a woman did not have any right to choose whom to marry, it was the prerogative of the male family member to choose. In the TV Serial, Rome, Julius 'Octavian' Caesar, who later became Augustus Caesar, makes a decision that affects both his mother and sister in a way unimaginable. The mother, Artia of the Julii is in love with Marcus Antonius (Mark Antony) and she plans to marry him. However, Caesar decides it will be impossible for the two lovebirds to make it official. For political reasons, he settles for his sister Octavia as a suitable wife for Mark Anthony! There are many examples of male subjugation in numerous cultu...
7 comments
Read more

NEGATIVE CULTURAL PRACTICES AMONG THE PEOPLE OF NASILA IN BLOSSOMS OF THE SAVANNAH

The book Blossoms of the Savannah explores both the positive and negative cultural practices. H. R Kulet describes intimately those cultural practices he believes are best and on the other hand, lets us in on some of the cultural practices he believe were injurious. Interestingly, the negative cultural practices are aimed at women. The most poignant cultural practice that negatively affects women is Female genital mutilation. Although according to Parmuat, the practice was started by women to resist the evil Ilarinkoi, it continued to cause wanton pain and torture on women. Taiyo and Resian are determined to fight it. Resian manages to evade the brutal practice however Taiyo barely makes it having been forcibly cut. FGM is a global menace affecting millions of women in Africa and Asia. Although its benefits are only anthropological, its effects are very damning and could lead to death.  Second among the negative Nasilian culture is early marriage. Resian still has go...
35 comments
Read more